The internet is a place where people's opinions have an equal platform to be heard, regardless of their authenticity or bias. I think in some circumstances people's opinion are appropriate if in a debate where it is about either party's opinion and such. However, the equal platform that the internet offers people means that even the most idiotic person will, and most probably gain more attention then a legitimate, authoritative source on a particular topic. In this way, the Internet does kill culture because you can clearly see that there are a whole lot more nonsensical content on the internet than anything that will truly benefit someone's life.
Youtube, for example has brought quality artists (music and otherwise) to popularity but (in my opinion, it's the internet I can say what I like) artists such as Soulja Boy who have been seen to degrade the value of hip hop music. I can agree with Andrew Keen when he says "the traditional media gatekeepers lose their power, the very idea of cultural authority is undermined, meaning that everybody (ie: nobody) can legitimately determine aesthetic standards or truths". However, I still have to disagree with the same point. The "traditional gatekeepers" are not always the best, they control and have the say in what the public gets to see. Social platforms such as Myspace and Youtube almost make it like a contest where the artist who garners the most attention (and hits) on their pages are more likely to be picked up by a big record company such as Lily Allen and others. This has definitely widened the variety that we have in our culture today, good and bad regardless.
I agree with Emily Bell when she says "this is not the problem of the web or the internet but the problem of those creative "industries", many of them are threatened by the rapid change of consumerist habits from high street retail to internet retail. They would argue that it is because the internet is killing them. Those creative industries were the "gatekeepers" as Keen says of the content of our culture. However now, the internet and its remix culture has allowed anyone and everyone to have a hand in creating brand new content from old content. How anyone could have a problem with it is a mystery to me, as most of the time the new content sounds nothing like the original and would never be associated with the company that owns the original content in the first place.
In my opinion (and in Keen's opinion, my entirely unfounded and biased opinion) the Internet has opened up the world to artists we may never have seen without it. Unfortunately, the industry could not keep up with these changes and have just reacted to the situation rather than thinking out a solution they may not be bad if they tried.
References:
http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2007/aug/10/andrewkeenvemilybell
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment